The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Grice -- a 'behaviourist'?

The word 'behaviourism' is misapplied when used in connection with Grice, or applied to Grice, if I may be redundant or contradictory.

Grice was _not_ a behaviourist. _Ryle_ was a behaviourist. Grice was an _intentionalist_.

The polemic perhaps started in 1971 when Searle reprinted Grice WoW:vi in is "Philosphy of Language" Oxford collection, ed. Warnock. This had Chomsky, in Reflections of Language, join the Searleans. Grice is a behaviourist, and the ULTIMATE behaviourist at that: look at his talk of 'have a procedure in one's repertoire' in terms of basic resultant procedures. The epitome of Watson!

-- The last straw(man) was Biro, "Grice is so behaviourist he hurts". But us Griceans know better.

In the pages of that cherrished volume, PGRICE, ed. Grandy and Warner -- and now Chapman in her bio -- has clarified things. Suppes reivindicates Grice as an intentionalist -- and Chapman relying on the UNITY or continuity of Grice's thoughts -- eg. his early "Intention and Disposition", joins in.

Etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment