* * * * * By J. L. Speranza, F. R. S. (failed), &c.
* * * * * * * for The Grice Club, THIS BLOG.
IN HIS COMMENTARY (dated March 1, 2010 1:58 PM) to "Reading between the lines", Billy Blogbather said,
"What the hell?"
The implicature of this one always amused me. It was first implicated by Philo (not the Philo familiar to philosophers, and creator of the horseshoe of logical implication -- to wit, "⊃"; as in "Cogito ⊃ Sum". No, this is the Philo of the I-Loeb-Loeb. Philo said, in Latin,
quid infernum
sic in Latin, and the implicature stuck. As Revd Clark Greggson writes in "Adventures of a Pilgrim", vol. ii, ad 4, "Had he said, 'What the Heaven', we perhaps would not be still here".
Blogblather continues:
"I must have made a wrong turn
back there."
The metaphor here is pure. The irony of the equi-polence between the "must" (deontic 'must' of 'chance' or 'random') and the teological character of the adjective chosen ('wrong') makes you wonder
This CANNOT be "Hell" ("Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'intrate"
Blogblather:
"I came looking for God, that
in-principio-erat-verbum God,
who without language would not be."
The exegetical heterodoxy turned orthodoxy via the "Logos" -- or ΛΟΓΟΣ -- of the Grecians.
Blogblather:
"I was expecting thunder voices
rumbling across the sky but
all I find is quibbling over
accent marks and snickering
over otiosities. We are language,
embodied language, we are the God we seek,
we are the universe, the galaxy,
the quark, we are our only
reason for living."
The writing in the body comprises the 'reading-between-the-lines' metaphor. In this case, Blogblather aims at the Scriptural basis of 'em-bodied' [Greek, 'soma'] of the 'logos' or 'sign' -- but also 'grave':
Vide: "The problem of the Soul in Aristotle's De Anima:
www.socinian.org/aristotles_de_anima.html
"In Plato, the soul and the body are two
different realities. His catch-phrase:
"soma--sema" (the body a sepulchre)."
Billy Blogblather continues:
"I keep pushing outward, pressing
forward with my ignorance as a
kind of black light flashlight,
following my confusion to a new
awareness of our possibilities."
Oddly, 'flashlight' can retrieve the wrong implicature, is played in software. Judy Evans has elsewhere reported:
http://www.freelists.org/post/lit-ideas/Political-Schadenfreude,5
"I say “boggle”, it hears “ogle”. I say “what time is it?", it hears “times it”. I say “worthy”, it hears “warranty”. I say “flashlight”, it hears “fleshlight”".
Billy Blogblather goes on:
"Language is the Galaxy we ride,
racing ever outward at ever
increasing speed; I don't care
how U-speakers speak.
I'm busy creating God."
Gallaxy hapens to be a very good one: The Grecians ("Multiply gods beyond necessity") had Hera and Zeus and the milk from her mammary gland [gluktos].
http://www.udu.cas.cz/collegium/tintoretto.pdf:
Chaucer:
See yonder, lo, the Galaxyë
Which men clepeth the Milky Wey,
For hit is whyt.
And Zeus placed his first-born sonne
By a mortal woman:
the infant Heracles, he.
And verily clumsilee, on the tittes
of his divine wyff Hera,
while she asleep was deep.
And the infant drank and drank
off her divine milk
and did thus immortal was. Byt Hera
woke up as breastfeeding the brat she were,
and then as realises she is
nursing an unknown infant, for it were not hers,
she pushes the baby away from her tittes,
whyle a jett of her white pure milk sprayed
the night sky, as it produced
the flow off the now faynted
band of light known as the Milky Wey
of the Galaxyë.
The House of Fame
vide J. M. Geary on Chaucer,
MA programme, Phil-Lit, Theoria, Lit-Ideas
J. L. S.
Appendix
Here by courtesy of
http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/000132.html
-------------------------------
------ The Maxims of Blog -----
I. Maxim of Enlightenment:
--- 1. Bring enlightenment.
--- 2. Wear shades.
* * * *
II. Maxim of Controversy:
--- 1. Be controversial. (Occasionally say what you are certain is true. It adds credibility.)
--- 2. Hint at that for which you have no evidence.
* * * *
III. Maxim of Digression:
Digress. (Especially (auto)biographically. Note that Gorky was born Aleksey Maksimovich Peshkov, and "Maxim" derives from his Father's name, the "-ovich" being a patronymic ending. Thus does one Maxim beget another. Hopefully, more on Russian and other naming conventions in a later log. And perhaps someone more literary or political than I will have something to say about "the father of Soviet literature and the founder of the doctrine of socialist realism," and the reason Nizhny Novgorod was for many years hard to find on a map. The Nizhny Novgorodites are still proud of Gorky as far as I can tell, but not enough to have their city bear his name. (Beaver, Utah is not named for me (or vice versa (note the embedded parenthetical - these are good)), but it is apparently the birthplace of Butch Cassidy, ne Robert LeRoy Parker. So why "Butch"? Well, he once worked as a butcher. His most famous partner in crime (aka Harry Longabaugh) was nom de guerred in a reverse Gorky manoever: as a young horse rustler the Kid spent two years in jail in Sundance, Wyoming. Not much going on in my name, except that Beaver is supposedly a case of very poor translation by English officials helping my ancestors anglicize their Polish family name, "Kaczka", which means "duck". David Duck.))
* * * *
IV. Maxim of Entropy:
-- 1. Hyperlink obscure expressions.
-- 2. Keep 'em guessing.
-- 3. Use acronyms.
-- 2. Maximize entropy. Stream consciousness. Order pizza.
Monday, March 1, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
For working 'fleshlight' into that, I salute you.
ReplyDeleteYou missed an implicature?
"I must have taken a wrong turn..." = "YOU ALL took a wrong turn, and now my Shining Path of Truth has delivered me into your gibbering midst, from where I must deploy my array of veiled and not-so-veiled insults, and flee, for I am making God/whoopee/trouble..."
And, after the logos of the Grecians, the blogos of the Griceians...
ReplyDelete"I'm busy creating God."
ReplyDeleteAnd we're all busily not creating God, therefore...
Like the people in commercials, come to life.
"Hey, I just saved 500 big ones on my car insurance..."
"Sure, I quit smoking, but I wear the patch..."
"I'm not covered in suppurating sores..."
"I did not spend the entirety of last night uncontrollably breaking wind..."
"That's right, pal, I'm busy making God, and so could you, with my new Easy-to-Follow Guide. Week by week, the Blogblather Encyclopaedia of Why I am Right and Everybody Else is Wrong grows into an enormous tangle of insult, spiritual insight, homespun knowledge and non sequiturs, an appallingly immense work that you will wish to sit around contemplating for centuries in the discomfort of your own bizarrely trivial home. But don't take my word for it, just believe me when I invoke almighty God (holds up God/sock puppet) "Say something God!" "BUY THE BOOK!" "You see, that's Divine Truth, from God, via my hand, to your ears. Now break out the wallet and splash da moolah..." Peace out, plebs..."
The whole thing is an object lesson in self-aggrandisement and its necessary counterpoint, other-diminishment.
I just placed myself on the divine scale in my bathroom and found I had made 0.36kg of God since I went to sleep last night. That is twice the average amount (or could it be that chocolate crepe and large capucino distorting the result?)
Interesting comments, Jason. Thank you. The blogos thing is an interesting conception. Thanks for the pun. I would THINK the idea of the 'log' is nautical in origin, but I'd need to check. Yes, we know the 'b' is the last letter of 'web' -- but in any case, whoever coined "blog" was perhaps thinking on the 'nautical' 'log' which would make sense vis a vis 'surfing' or 'cybernaut'. We should also discuss the etymology of 'blather' since I omitted that. I did not feel insulted by Billy Blogblather but apologise on his behalf if any other of the commenters on "Reading between the lines" did. I trust he meant no evil. I hope maybe he can address your interesting points you make. Yes, I ignored the implicature you mentioned, "You are wrong, I am right". I drive like crazy, so any metaphor reading with 'reverse', 'wrong turn', etc. has such vividness with me, that I usually disimplicate them. I think I missed, Jason, your interesting points about the commercials, but will re-read them and find out. Thanks for the input.
ReplyDeleteJL, I think, maybe it is just me, but, I see a direct link between religiosity in the West, at least, and commercials.
ReplyDeleteI call it 'the outrageous unsubstantiated claim', this is why I see the religious billboards around Guatemala City as perfectly at home alongside the one's for chicken or new Edox wristwatches, etc, they flow from the same source. My favourite is the one that says "Para Dios todo es posible."
Hello to Mr Blather, too.
Kennedy:
ReplyDelete"maybe it is just me, but, I see a direct link between religiosity in the West, at least, and commercials."
No, there probably is (there to be seen). Regard this implicature by Grice:
"Again, if someone were to say,
'He's just an evangelist"
he might mean, perhaps:
'He is a sanctimonious, hypocritical, racist, reactionary, money-grubber".
WoW:361. Grice uses this as an example of 'meaning-equivalence' or 'synonymy':
"If in such a case the meaning were as suggested, it might well be claimed that what he meant was in fact what his words said"
Only words don't 'say'!
Grice goes on:
"in which case, his words would be DICTIVE but their DICTIVE content would be nonformal [in fact, rude. JLS -- pehaps] and NOT part of the conventional meaning of the words used ['he', 'is', 'an', 'evangelist'. JLS]. We should thus find dictiveness without formality." WoW, 1987, p. 361. That a man diagnosed with emphysema and with copious stuff on eschatology and methodological metaphysics to edit should expand on such examples is a _charmer_.
J. Kennedy's other examples of 'commercials':
"Hey, I just saved 500 big ones on my car insurance...", "Sure, I quit smoking, but I wear the patch..." "I'm not covered in suppurating sores..." "I did not spend the entirety of last night uncontrollably breaking wind..." "That's right, pal, I'm busy making God, and so could you, with my new 'Easy-to-Follow Guide': week by week: The Blogblather Encyclopædia Of Why I Am Right & Everybody Else Is Wrong grows into an [endless] source Spiritual Insight, that you will wish to sit around contemplating in æternvm. Take My Word for it & believe me when I invoke almighty God [At this point Billy holds up God-sock puppet, 'Say something God!" -- "Jesus Grice Almighty!"). Billy: "You see, that's Divine Truth, from God, via my hand, to your ears, and landing on Amazing Griceland".
Yes.
Can God implicate?
All speech as ventriloquism.
ReplyDeleteAmen.
Equally, "He's just a God..."
ReplyDeleteYes, I often wondered. There was in Buenos Aires a pretty popular double act, "Chasman and Chirolita" -- a ventriloquist duo. My mother laughed and laughed. Oddly, in a sequence of "Radio Days" by Woody Allen, this lady is listening to the 'wireless', and she can't help laughing so uproariously at the radio variete show. The husband, practical type, says, "I can't see what you find so funny". "It's the ventriloquist double act". "But this is the radio". I think that if we should find a script of a ventriquolist, we can analyse alla Grice. Oddly, the ventriquolist always plays the straight man (as Nowell-Smith in Grice's Play Group, say). I.e. the punchlines, and scary impicatures come from the puppet. Geary comments: "The problem with a Gricean analysis of ventriloquist talk underlooks the plain fact that it's only one person -- usually the one who gets paid -- who does the talking. Therefore the predictability of the generative projection of an embedded implicature, on the part of the [puppet] has to be analysed, beyond Grice, in terms of полифония, of polyphony if you must in what Bakhtin said on this (in Russian, alas, which not all of my students have)."
ReplyDeleteJ. Kennedy, with the creativity that he _is_ (never mind 'characterises') wrote:"[A]fter the logos of the Grecians, the blogos of the Griceians" Or in Greek if you must
ReplyDeleteΒΛΟΓΟΣ
The speed of the blogos (Griceian) is measured by ratio of the distance travelled in the aggregate of the latitude and longitude of Grice to the 'timeless' meaning of the Eternal Truth. In symbols,
Lat (G) + Long (G)
_______________________
Eternal Truth
This takes place in the "Sea of Languages". As Grice notes the importance of the berth before we are off to the seas of language. For, as Chapman exegesises, "opinion is gneerally reflected in alngauge, with different 'levels' representing different degrees of commitment. Some aspects of knoweldge receive the deepest levels of embedding within syntax, residing in what Grice describes as the 'deep berths' of algnague. It is NOT possible for a speaker even to USE the language without being committed to thse. The deepest levels are at a premium , so it is in the interests of speakers to reserve these for their deepest commitments. And the speed at which we proceed at the Club may vary, hence the ultimate importance of the Blogos, for which I trust our timber tructure is of the excellent type [logbook, so-called because wooden [log] floats were used to measure a ship's speed (1679).]