To what extent a fallacious arguer is "arguing"?
Should we restrict "arguing" or "reasoning" to
"good" samples?
(cfr Luciano Fioridi on information).
I don't think so!
I would use Grice's word "aspect".
There is a good aspect (positively valued) of reasoning, and
There is a bad aspect (negatively valued),
where - within the latter - I would distinguish betweeen
1. fallacy (Griceanly UNINTENTIONAL)
(nobody wants to commit a mistake intentionally)
2. SOPHISM (Griceanly intentional)
qua figure of SPEECH, or rather
STRATEGEM
i.e. a rational strategy
intented NOT to be recognised by
one's co-conversationalist.
I title all this "Sesquipedanialism" after my mentor in this area, DV Druff.
The idea is that you have to use a technical name to label a fallacy so that
it comes to existence (My point being to what extent knowing what TYPE of
fallacy/sophism one is indulging in helps clarify the matter).
ad vericundiam,
ad baculum,
propter,
hominem,
lapidem,
misericordiam,
mulierem,
non causa pro causa,
intra dictionem, etc...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
OK I'll bite. For "sesquipedanialism" to make sense, the D in D.V. Druff would have to stand for "Dan." Dan Druff was your mentor? That flake?
ReplyDeleteOops. I was never so witty. It was merely a typo for "sesquipedalianism", now a new entry. Sorry, D. V. Druff!
ReplyDeleteThe mistake is easy to make. You were probably thinking of Sesquipedaniel, the porn star with the foot-and-a-half long impregnatorial instrument.
ReplyDeleteYou think. Arnold Zwicky, who has a porn story on the internet somewhere, and coined his "uninvited inferences" with Geiss -- which I rebutted in "The Uninvited Implicature" -- has examined the law behind:
ReplyDeleteWystan Arenales
-- the name of my pet and the name of my street.
He has studied male porn star names. He thinks that:
-- First, porn-writers are WITTY: there is NOT one single porn film which has a literal title to it. They all _implicate_: they have resonances that go beyond the erection. They are meant for enjoyment of the _intellect_.
-- The names are usually 'artistic', as Sesquipedaniel.Unless you are saying that was his _Christian_ name?