The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

"Mean Mr. Mustard" vide "Grip of a Vyse"

As Grice notes,

'mean' sometimes means good things.
Sometimes 'bad'.

But that's AEQUI-vocal. They are the same 'vox' but hardly the same 'meaning'!

-- For consider:

Mean Mister Mustard sleeps in the park
Shaves in the dark trying to save paper
Sleeps in a hole in the road
Saving up to buy some clothes
Keeps a ten bob note up his nose
Such a mean old man
Such a mean old man

His sister Pam works in a shop
She never stops, she's a go-getter
Takes him out to look at the queen
Only place that he's ever been
Always shouts out something obscene
Such a dirty old man
Such a dirty old man

---

Mean Mister Mustard sleeps in the park
Shaves in the dark trying to save paper

-- meaning?
I cannot see how dark will economise on tree timber.


Sleeps in a hole in the road

-- Oddly. I feel I want to mean, "the whole in a road".

--

Saving up to buy some clothes
Keeps a ten bob note up his nose
Such a mean old man
Such a mean old man

-- Oddly, this Father-Williams feature in Mustard's character displays him as rather unmeany, rather (at least he does not keep keep us his ears!


-- ABRUPT change of topic here:

His sister Pam works in a shop
She never stops, she's a go-getter
Takes him out to look at the queen
Only place that he's ever been

-- alla A cat may look at the Quean?
I'm irritated that we are not provided the locale.
Somehow, I'm thinking Penny Lane.
And 'only' is hyperbolic here:
he's been to a whole in the road, too.
not to mention the da:k pa:k.


Always shouts out something obscene
Such a dirty old man
Such a dirty old man

-- Oddly, Lennon became one in due time. Just joking. Love the man!

Etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment