The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

The Implicatures of Prick

L. Horn in an essay for the Linguistic Society of America, 'Lexical
pragmatics meets he-man', where he refers to



"[T]he known diachrony of "man" [...] in
which a super-set sex-NEUTRAL use
gradually yielded to the cognitively
prototypic 'sense' [...] In English,
an earlier symmetric "ABC" set-up gave
way to an imbalanced "AAB" structure
that has prevailed since the mediaeval period.



OE "mann": --> MnE "man"


"werman", "wifman" "human "male"
"waepnedman" person" (vs. "woman")



"Significantly the basic level of categorisation
(Rosch 1978) for reference to 'human' was in OE at
the super-set level. ... The English schema is
mirrored in Romance with originally gender-neutral
"homo" picking up the [+male] feature and replacing
"vir." ... What the diachrony of "man" reveals is
not the imperialism of BROADENING ... but
the USURPATION of the sex-neutral that yields
NARROWING."

Etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment