The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Grice Takes The Lead, 1960-67

Of the Play Group that is.

From Owen, obit of Ryle, Aristotelian Society:

"In the later 1930s, two fairly jealously guarded groups of senior philosophers were meeting in Oxford. One inaugurated some ten years earlier, included

G. Ryle,
JD Mabbot

[of St. John's -- he mentions Grice in
his autobiography, Oxfod Memories, 1986. JLS],

H H Price, and
R. W. Hardie [Grice's tutor at
Corpus. JLS] and at different times

C S Lewis,
W C Kneale, and
D Cox.

It met fortnightly for dinner and discussion and was formally disbanded some
forty years after its conception. The younger group began later and
dissolved earlier. It included

JL Austin,
I Berlin [co-student with Grice
at Corpus, also tutee of Hardie],
SN Hampshire,
AJ Ayer,
HLA Hart, and HP Grice.

----

Grice confesses: "rarely -- I had been brought up on the wrong side of the tracks"

----

"Its weekly meetings were continued and enlarged after the war [when,
with loads of people going back to 'varsity, Oxford was _the place to be
doing philo_], and

carried on after the loss of Austin by Grice until he
left Oxford."

[That would mean 1967. JLS]

"There was no overlap, or only the most occasional and contingent, in the
membership of these groups. Their motivations were different [...] There
was no Vienna behind them [the first group]; as there was behind the group
that started in the 1930s. ... Neither of the two Oxford grups came near to
a cult,

though perhaps the later came nearer" (p. 270).

Etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment