The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Friday, October 24, 2014

Harborne Revisited: Rosebushes and cherry-trees

Speranza

"In favour of Minimalism we might hear an appeal
to the beauty of 'desert landscapes'. But such
an appeal I would regard as inappropriate; we
are not being asked by a Minimalist to give our
vote to a special, and no doubt very fine, type
of landscape; we are being asked to express our
preference for an ordinary sort of landscape at
a recognisably lean time; to rosebushes and
cherry-trees in mind-winter, rather than in
spring or summer. What bothers me about what
I am being offered is not that it is bare, but
that it has been systematically and relentlessly
undressed" Grice, op.cit.
In R Grandy & R Warner, eds. P.G.R.I.C.E.,
Philosophical Grounds of Rationality:
Intentions, Categories, Ends. Oxford, p.68

No comments:

Post a Comment