The Grice Club


The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Max Black on Herbert Paul Grice


Max Black's father was Lionel Black who was a businessman.
Max Black's mother was Sophia Davinska.
Both Lionel Black and Sophia Davinska were Jewish.

As a consequence suffered from the anti-Semitism which was widespread at this time in Azerbaijan.
Soon after Max was born his parents decided to try to make a better life for their family in a less hostile place and they left Azerbaijan moving first to Paris.
After a short stay in Paris, the Blacks moved again, this time to London, where they set up home in 1912.
Black was only three years old when his family set up home in England and all his education took place in that country.
This meant that despite his Jewish-Russian background he grew up assimilating English culture, something which showed through in his later philosophical writings.
He was extremely talented as a child and showed great abilities in both mathematics and music.
In particular he played the violin to a very high standard and during his time at school he contemplated a career in music, thinking that he would be a professional pianist.
So did Herbert Paul Grice! Grice played Debussy and Ravel while at Clifton!
Another of his talents was for chess -- as was Grice's -- which, like the violin, he played to a high standard.
It was a game he enjoyed throughout his life.
By the time he had completed his schooling Max Black had decided on a career in mathematics rather than music.
He entered Queen's, Cambridge and found that there were many there interested in the philosophy of mathematics.
Russell, Witters, G. E. Moore, and Frank Plumpton Ramsey were all teaching at Cambridge during Black's time as an undergraduate and the influence that these people had on Black was very major indeed for they turned his interests towards philosophy.
He graduated with his B.A. in 1930 and was awarded a fellowship to enable him to study at Göttingen for a year.
At Göttingen, Black worked on his first book The nature of mathematics.
He had two principal aims in mind when he wrote this work.
The first was to present a considered critical exposition of Whitehead's and Russell's Principia mathematica.
The scond was to give supplementary accounts of the formalist and intuitionist doctrines in sufficient detail to make it easy for those wished to proceed further to read the original papers.
His presentation of Brouwer's intuitionism was particularly fine.
The nature of mathematics was first published in 1933 and a photographic reprint was published over a quarter of a century later in 1959.
Black married Michal Landsberg around this time.
They had two children.
He returned from Göttingen after his year there and studied for his doctorate at the University of London.
His doctoral dissertation was Theories of logical positivism and he was awarded the degree in 1939.
Two years earlier he had published a work Vagueness: An exercise in logical analysis in the Philosophical Society.
In this work he looked at two main ideas, one being the nature of and the observability of vagueness and the other one being the relevance vagueness might have for logic.
The "vague sets" which Black wrote about in this paper are now called "fuzzy sets" and, had his paper made more impact at the time, then our terminology today might be different.
It was the first attempt to give a precise mathematical theory for sets where there is a membership curve.
In this work Black wrote:-
The vagueness of the word chair is typical of all terms whose application involves the use of the senses. In all such cases "borderline cases" and "doubtful objects" are easily found to which we are unable to say either that the class name does or does not apply.
Black lectured on mathematics at the Institution of Education in London from 1936 until 1940 when he accepted an appointment to the Philosophy Department at the University of Illinois at Urbana.
After six years at Urbana, Black accepted a professorship in philosophy at The Sage School, Cornell, in Ithaca. 
Black continued to work at Cornell becoming Susan Linn-Sage Professor of Philosophy and Humane Letters there in 1954.
He retired in 1977 but continued lecturing at many universities world-wide.
He was President of the International Institute of Philosophy from 1981 until 1984, being only the second American ever to hold this position.
Black was famed for his contributions to the philosophy of language, the philosophy of mathematics and science, the philosophy of art, conceptual analysis, and his studies of the work of philosophers such as Frege (publishing a major work in 1952) and Wittgenstein (publishing A companion to Wittgenstein's Tractatus in 1964).
Black was a prolific author and lists of his publications contain over 200 items. Among them is a piece on Herbert Paul Grice.
One of Black's early books on philosophy was Language and Philosophy which he published in 1949.
His earlier work on vagueness from ten year before was produced again in this work and he applied the same ideas to language arguing that the rules of discourse could not be followed precisely.
In 1954 Black published Problems of Analysis which examined the problems associated with induction, namely making generalisations and predictions based on a few cases.
As in many of his arguments Black insists that in the end one can trust inductive arguments if they are seen to work and he argues that common sense must always be used.
In Models and Metaphors (1962) argued that:-
... the conception of language as a mirror of reality is radically mistaken ...
and that language should attempt to:-
... conform to the discovered regularities of experience.
Mathematics was never far from Black's approach to topics, as for example one of his latter works Making intelligent choices, how useful is decision theory? published in 1985.
This provided a survey of Bayesian decision theory and contains data to illustrate his point that actual choosers often do not behave like good Bayesians.
P L Quinn, surveying this paper writes:-
The author argues that rational choosers will not always treat their options as given but will instead often actively structure them by a kind of "preselection" which involves tacit choice among various intentional descriptions of the salient features of the choice situation. He also argues that violations of transitivity in the chooser's preference ordering need not be symptoms of irrationality. [Black suggests] that intelligent choice might well be thought of as the exercise of an informal, practical art, rather than the application of a mathematical calculus.
Black described himself as a 
... lapsed mathematician, addicted reasoner, and devotee of metaphor and chess.
As a philosopher, he was known for offering a commonsense, pragmatic approach to those theoretical issues that he knew required clarity.
Highly sceptical of those who offered facile classifications, Black sought to confirm what can be known about the world and yet was ever mindful of the tentative nature that characterised most philosophical investigations.

No comments:

Post a Comment