The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Thursday, January 28, 2010

The Implicatures of Being Dead

In "Naturalism without tears", this blog, our excellent correspondent L. J. Kramer has expanded on the 'various idioms' relating to dead:

i. He is dead
ii. He kicked the bucket
iii. He _is_ kicking the bucket +> ?? He is dying
iv. He is fertilising the daffodils (WoW v)
v. He is helping the grass to grow
vi. He is pushing up the daisies
vii. ?? He bought a farm.
viii. He bought _the_ farm.
ix. He joined the featherly choir.
x. He ceased to be a spatio-temporal continuant (Strawson, Individuals: an essay in descriptive metaphysics)
xi. He passed.
xii. He passed _away_.
xiii. He _died_.

etc.

Apparently, Anglo-Phones have a problem with 'death'. Not so the Germans. As the Austrian engineer wittily commented, "To die is not a part of life".

And then some bad'uns say, "Life is a blog and then you die".

"Get a life". Shouldn't you answer _them_ by telling them to get a death, their-selves?

JLS

1 comment:

  1. The philosophical point I would like to consider -- but all are welcomes: a space is a place with _many_ points -- is that

    1. Jack is dead.

    amounts to a reference to a Gricean 'vacuous name' (vide his "Vacuous Names"), to wit: "Jack".

    Therefore, it is neither true nor false.

    cfr.

    ii. ??The present King of France is dead.

    ReplyDelete