The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Thursday, April 22, 2010

(False) Things People Say (Was: "Never Say Never")

----

If people know they are knowingly something very stupid when they say, "Never say never", why do they say it?

The same holds for:

"Joan Rivers is not 45 years old; she is 73 years old."

Logically, if she has lived 73 years, she has, by default, ALSO lived 45 years old.

Metalinguistic negation is a no-no.

-----

Consider:

"It is not hot; it is warm."

This makes perfect sense.

But the American expression:

"It is not warm; it is HOT!"

does not. It is FALSE. People yet say it.

The maxim goes:

"Say the truth!"

Yet people, illogically, say things which are false -- at least in regions of the world -- Cfr. "My lips are sealed", "I don't like you; I LOVE you!", and so on.

A Griceian has to give deaf ears to such absurdities, which goes etymologically hand in hand with what ab-surd means: deaf.

No comments:

Post a Comment