The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Friday, January 29, 2010

Grecian Gricean -- Gricean Grecian

Chapman notes re: Grice's notes in "Aspects of Reason" on

volitive
imperative
optative
inquisitive

etc.

"For [most] modes, ... the syntax [grammar] of English does not reflect [variants]" (p. 132 of Chapman). I note marginally:

I would submit that, like Austin -- I'm all with Austin & Grice in my head as I write having found out that they are THE key authors in a recent "Key Terms in Pragmatics".

--- Grice was more confident (confidant?) with

GREEK

and second,

LATIN

-- Oxonian credo reverses Shakespeare there --.

grammar than he would be with _English_ grammar. Recall that until the French came to existence, with their myth ("French is a logical language"), English grammarians would often rely on _Latin_ grammar (Priscian) which would herself rely on _Greek_ grammar (Thrax) to _label_ things.

In other words, Grice's reflections on a mode or two NOT being 'realised' syntactically, or morphologically, if you must, in this or that Language (e.g. English as opposed to say Greek) need to be taken with _three_ pinches of _oregano_.

No comments:

Post a Comment