The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Grice plays Pavane pour une infante défunte

This is what we -- well, S. R. -- was able to excavate by contacting T[homas] J. Grover, of the Old Cliftonian Society:


---

Quotation courtesy of the Old Cliftonian Society:

--- From end-of-year concert, 1930 -- "The Clifonian"


----

"We enjoyed Grice's playing of Ravel's "Pavane";"


----- Grice was 17.


The review goes to focus on

"its stateliness"

----

where 'its' refers to

(m) mainly: Grice's playing
(less mainly): the Pavane itself.

---- (Surely I can play the Pavane in a non stately manner -- I can even murder the tune with the left pedal, too -- and turn it into a Lambeth Walk).

----


The reviewer is eager to contrast the 'stateliness' of Grice's performance with his companion, who had played the rather unBritish Rachmaninoff.

"[Grice's 'Ravane''s] "stateliness

provided an effective contrast to the

exuberance of the Rachmaninoff"

as played by Joseph Cooper.

(Oddly, Cooper never studied philosophy, but run the BBC television programme, "Face the music" --, and he was also a concert pianist.

The Pavane should have some text to it.

I can think of various lines that may fit the piece.

The important thing about finding lyrics to a non-lyrical piece is to match the spirit. If this is a pavane for a dead princess, we expect appropriately funeral lyrics -- not anything about robins in spring, say.

The music itself usually 'invites' a certain setting. If it's a minor key it's usually sad, unless the lyrics are meant as 'funny'.

No comments:

Post a Comment