The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Saturday, April 4, 2020

H. P. Grice's seven-step derivation of buletic acceptability

(1) 

Fundamental law that (ceteris paribus) for any creature x (for any A, B), if x wills A and judges that if A, then A as a result of B; then x wills B. 

(2) 

x wills that (for any A, B) if x wills A and judges that if A, A as a result of B, then x is to will that B. 

(3) 

x should (qua rational) judge that (for any A, B) if it is satisfactory to will that A and also satisfactory to judge that if A, A only as a result of B, then it is satisfactory to will that B. 

(4) 

x should (qua rational) judge that (for any A, B) if it is satisfactory that ! A and also satisfactory that if A, then A only as a result of B, then it is satisfactory that ! B. 

(5) 

x should (q.r.) judge that (for any A, B) if it is satisfactory that if A, A only because B, then it is satisfactory that, if let it be that A, then let it be that B. 

(6) x should (q.r.) judge that (for any A, B) if A, A only because B, yields if let it be that A, then let it be that B. 

(7) (For any A, B) if A, A only because B yields if let it be that A, then let it be that B.

No comments:

Post a Comment