The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

The Answering Machine

Speranza

Avramides in:

http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/04/remembering-michael-dummett/

"Park Town is where he raised his family, and he was as much a part of Park Town life as he was of university life. Over a cup of tea he would tell a story or make an observation — followed by his infectious giggle. Michael once explained that he made a telephone call only to be put through to the answering machine. He observed: “They call it an answering machine but it’s not. You can ask it questions, but it won’t give you any answers.”"

In symbols:

Fallacious:

"Michael once explained that he made a telephone call only to be put through to the answering₂machine. He observed: “They call it an answering₁machine but it’s not [an answering₁machine]. You can ask it questions, but it won’t give you any answers₁.”" [Followed by infectious giggle].

Non-Fallacious:

"Michael once explained that he made a telephone call only to be put through to the answering₂machine. He observed: “They call it an answering₂machine [but mind:] it’s not [an answering₁machine]. You can ask it questions, but it won’t give you any answers₁[Only answers₂].”"

As suggested elsewhere, the idea is to re-analyse the example alla Grice in terms of disimplicature and his [Grice's] 'modified Occam's razor': senses should not be multiplied beyond necessity.

No comments:

Post a Comment