The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Quinton defends Oxonian Grice versus outsider Gellner

-- by JLS
-- for the GC

Quinton wrote in his review of Ernest Gellner, "Words and things" in the British Journal for the Philosophy of Science:

"Both its style and its content show it
to a pamphlet rather than a fully-fledged
philosophical treatise."

----

"It is written in a none too orderly way."

"Its sociological excursions are marginally relevant."

"Mr. Gellner does not exert himself to identify
very clearly the precise object of his attack;
linguistic philosophy remains to the end a
pretty shapeless affair".

"He relies on stray journalistic lettings-down
of hair."

When he analyses a special case, the result is

"frivolous (...

"uses but not sentences refer"

(I have a terrible feeling I may have gotten the
phrasing of this latter idea wrong)")"

----

No comments:

Post a Comment