Grice's "Personal Identity": the logical form and the implicature

GRICE'S REFERENCES:

Alexander, S., 
Self as Subject and as Person,
Aristotelian Society Proceedings , Vol. 11 (1910-1911), pp. 1-28. 2. 

Allison, Henry E., 
Locke on Personal Identity
Journal of the History of Ideas
Vol. 27 (1966), pp. 41-58. 3. 

Anderson, R. F., 
Locke on the Knowledge of Material Things" , Journal of the History of Philosophy , Vol. 3 (1965), pp. 205-215

Anscombe, G. E. M. , "The Principle of Individuation," The Aristotelian Society , Sup pi . Vol. XXVII (1953), pp. 83-96. 5. 

Ayer, A. J. , "The Concept of a Person," in The Concept of a Person and Other Essays , New York, 1963. 

Barclay, K. C., "Geach, Locke and Nominal Essences," Philo sophic al Studies , Vol. 18 (1967), pp. 78-80. 

Bennett, Jonathan, "The Simplicity of the Soul," Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 64 (1967), pp. 648-660. 

Brett, Nathan, "Substance and Mental Identity in Hume's 'Treatise'," Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 22 (1972), pp. 116-125. 

Broad, C, D., "Locke's Doctrine of Substantial Identity and Diversity," Theoria , Vol. 17 (1951). 

The Mind and Its Place in Nature , London, 1925, Ch. 6. 10 -- cited by Grice.

Brody, B. A. , "Is there a Philosophical Problem about the Identity of Substances?" Philosophia , Vol. 1 (1971), pp. 43-59. "Locke on the Identity of Persons," American Philosophical Quarterl y, Vol. 9 (1972), pp, 327-334. "Natural Kinds and Real Essences," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 64 (1967), pp. 431-446. "Why Settle for Anything Less than Good Old-Fashioned Aristotelian Essentialism?" Nous, Vol. 7 (1973), pp. 351-365. 

Butler, Joseph, "Of Personal Identity," First Dissertation to The Analogy of Religion, ed. by W. E. Gladstone, Oxford, 1897. 

Care, Norman S. and Grimm, Robert H. , eds , Perception and Personal Identity , Cleveland, 1969. 

Chandler, Hugh S., "Constitutivity and Identity," Nous , Vol. 5 (1971, pp. 313-320. "A Note in Defense of Personal Materialism," Philo s ophic al St udies , Vol. 22 (1971), pp. 61-64. "Shoemaker's Arguments Against Locke," Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 19 (1969), pp. 263-265. "Wiggins on Identity," Analysi s , Vol. 29 (1969), pp. 173-174. 259 

Chapman, Tobias, "Identity and Reference," Mind , Vol. 82 (1973), pp. 542-556, 

Chappell, V. C., "Sameness and Change," Philosophical Review , Vol. 69 (1960), pp. 351-362. 16. Chisholm, R. , "Identity Through Possible Worlds: Some Questions," Nous , Vol. 1 (1967), pp. 1-8. "On the Observability of the Self," Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Vol. 30 (1969), pp. 7-21. 17.

 Clack, R. Jeroid, "Chisholm and Hume on Observing the Self," Philosophy and Phenomenological Research , Vol. 33 (1973), pp. 338-348. 

Clapp, James Gordon, Locke's Conception of the Mind , 1937. 19. Coburn, Robert C., "Bodily Continuity and Personal Identity, A Reply," Analysis , Vol. 21 (1960), pp. 43-48. "Persons and Psychological Concepts," American Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 4 (1967), pp. 208-221. 

Copi, I. M. , "Essence and Accident," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 51 (1954), pp. 706-719. 21. Cousin, Victor, Elements of Psychology , ed. and trans . by C. S. Henry, New. York, 1855. Phllosophie de Locke , Paris, 1861. 

Cowley, Fraser, "The Identity of a Person and His Body," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 68 (1971), pp. 678-683. 

Daniels, Charles B. , "Personal Identity," American Philosophical Quart erly , Vol. 6 (1969), pp. 226-232. 24. Donnelly, John and Lyons, L. S., "Recent Problems in Metaphysics," The New Scholasticism , Vol. 45 (1971), pp. 290-323. 25. Durrant, Michael, "Numerical Identity," Mind , Vol. 82 (1973), pp. 95-103. 

Eastwood, Gordon R. , "Person as Logical Construct," Paci f ic Philos o phy Forum , Vol. 6 (1968), pp. 53-66. 27. Feldman, Fred, "Counterparts," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 68 (1971). pp. 406-409. "Geach and Relative Identity," Review of Metaphysics , Vol. 22 (1969), pp. 547-555. 

Findlay, John. "Essence, Existence and Personality," Idealistic Studies , Vol. 3 (1973), pp. 106-116. 260 29. Flew, Antony, "Locke and the Problem of Personal Identity," in C. B. Martin and D. M. Armstrong, eds., Locke and Berkeley . Garden City, New York, 1968. "Selves," Mind, Vol. 58 (1949), pp. 355-358. 

Frondizi, Risieri, The Nature of the Self . New Haven, 1953. 31. 

Gabbay, D. and Moravcsik, J. M. , "Sameness and Individuation," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 70 (1973), pp. 513-526. 32. Gale, Richard M. , "A Note on Personal Identity and Bodily Continuity," Analysis , Vol. 29 (1969), pp. 193-195. 33. Geach, P. T., "Identity," Review of Metaphysics , Vol. 21 (1967), pp. 3-12. Reference and Generality , Ithaca, 1962. 34. Gert, Bernard, "Personal Identity and the Body," Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review, Vol. 10 (1971), pp. 458-478. 35. Gibson, James, Locke's Theory of Knowledge and its Historical Relations , Cambridge, 1960, 36. Gotesky, Rubin, "Some Unpersonal Remarks about Persons," Pacific Philosophy Forum , Vol. 6 (May, 1968), pp. 67-72. 37. Greenwood, Terence, "Personal Identity and Memory," Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 17 (1967), pp. 334-344. 38. 

Grice, H. P. , "Personal Identity," Mind , Vol. 50 (1941), pp. 330-350. 39, repr. in J. Perry, "Personal identity," 1971. 



Gruenenfelder , Jack, "Is Substance Relevant to Contemporary Concern with the Person?" The New Scho la sticism , Vol. 41 (1967), pp. 498- 505. 40. Haque, Intisar-ul, "The Person and Personal Identity," Philos ophy and Phenomenological Research , Vol. 31 (1970), pp. 60-72. 

Hartnack, J. , "Remarks on Personal Identity," Internationa l Logic Review , Vol. I (1970), pp. 107-110. 42. Harts’norne, Charles Z., "Personal Identity from A to Z," Proce ss S tudies , Vol. 2 (1372), pp, 209-215. 43. Hicks, G. Dawes; Laird, J. ; Dorward, Alan, The Nature of the Self and of Self-Consciousness , Aristotelian Society , Suppl. Vol. VIII (1928) , pp. 189-221. 

Hobbes, Thomas, Elements of Philosophy in Works , Vol. I, ed. by Sir William Molesworth, London, 1839. 45. Hofstadter, Albert, Locke and Scepticism , 1935. 262 61. Mabbott, J. D. , John Locke, London, 1973. 62. Marcus, R. B. , "Essential Attribution," Journal of Philosophy, Vol 68, (1971), pp. 187-202. 63. Martin, C. B. , Religious Belief, Ithaca, New York. 1959, Ch. 6. "Identity and Exact Similarity," Analysis , Vol. 18 (1958), pp. 83-87. 64. Merrill, Kenneth R. , "Comments on Professor H. D, Lewis, Self-Identity and Memory," Southwestern Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 1 (1970), pp. 230-239. ' 65. Minkus , P. A., Philosophy of the Person , Oxford, 1960, pp. 1-22. 66. Mrinal , Miri, "Memory and Personal Identity," Mind , Vol. 82 (1973), pp. 1-21. 67. Munitz, Milton K. , ed. , Identity and Individuation , New York, 1971. 68. Nelson, Jack, "Logically Necessary and Sufficient Conditions for Identity Through Time," American Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 9 (1972), pp. 177-185. "On the Alleged Incompleteness of Certain Identity Claims," C anadian Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 3 (1973), pp. 105-115. 69. Nelson, John 0., "Criteria and Personal Identity," Ratio , Vol. 15 (1973) , pp. 102-106. "Relative Identity," Nous , Vol. 4 (1970), pp. 241-260. 70. Nerlich, G. C., "Sameness, Difference and Continuity," Ana lysis , (1958), pp. 144-149. 71. Noxon, James, "Senses of Identity in Hume's Treatise," Dialogue Vol. 8 (1969), pp. 367-384. 72. O'Connor, D. J. , John Locke , New York, 1967. "Locke," in D. J. O'Connor, ed,, A Critical History of We s tern Philos ophy, Glencoe, Illinois, 1964. 73. Odega.rd, Douglas, "Essences and Discovery: Plato, Leibniz and Locke," Dialogue , Vol. 3 (1965), pp. 219-234. "Identity Through Time," American Philosophical Quarterly, Vol, 9 (1972), up. 29-38. "Locke and Mind-Body Dualism," Philosophy , Vol. 45, pp. 87-105. "Locke, Leibniz and Identical Propositions," Studia Leibnitiana. "Personal and Bodily Identity," Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 19 (1959), pp. 69-71 . "Persons and Bodies," Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Vol. 31 (1970), pp. 225-242, 265 74. Parfit, Derek A., "On 'The Importance of Self-Identity,'" Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 68 (1971), pp. 683-690. "Personal Identity," Philosophical Review , Vol. 80 (1971), pp. 3-27. 75. Paton, H. J. , "Self-Identity," in his In Defence of Reason , London, 1951. 76. Penelhume, Terence, "Hume on Personal Identity," Philosophical Review , Vol. 64 (1955), pp. 571-589. "The Importance of Self-Identity," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 68 (1971), pp. 667-678. "Personal Identity," in Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Vol. 6, pp. 95-107. "Personal Identity: Memory and Survival," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 67 (1959), pp. 882-903. ~ ' 77. Perry, David, "Locke on Mixed Modes, Relations and Knowledge," Journal of the History of Philosophy , Vol. 5 (1967), pp. 219-235. 78. Perry, John, "Can the Self Divide’" Journal of Philosophy. '' 7 ol. 69 (1972), pp. 463-488. "The Same F," Philosophical Review , Vol. 79 (1970), pp. 181-200. 79. Pike, Nelson, "Hume's Bundle Theory of the Self: A Limited Defense," American Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 4 (1967), pp. 159-165. 80. Popper, Karl R. , "The Principle of Individuation," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society , Suppl. Vol, XXVII (1953), pp. 97-120. 81. Prior, Arthur, "Opposite Number," Review of Metaphysics , Vol. 11 (1957) , pp. 196-201. "Time, Existence and Identity," Papers on Time and Tens e, Oxford, 1968. 82. Pucetti, R., "Remembering the Past of Another," Canadian Journal of Phi losophy , Vol. 2 (1973), pp. 523-532. 83. Quine, W. V., Review of Geach, Peter, Reference and Genera lity, Ph ilosophical Review , Vol. 73 (1964), p. 101. "Identity, Ostension, and Hypostasis," From a Logical Point of Vi ew, Cambridge, Mass., 1961. 84. Quinton, Anthony, "Two Conceptions of Personality," Revue Inter- nationale de Philosophie , Vol. 22 (1968), pp. 387-402. "The Soul," Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 59 (1962), pp. 393-409. 85. Reck, Andrew J. , "Some Critical Remarks on H. D. Lewis, Self-Identity and Memory," Southwestern Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 1 (1970) pp. 224-229. 86. Reid, Thomas, Es says on the Intellectual Powers of Man , Essay III. Cambridge, 1853. 87. 264 Reinett, Herbert R. , "The Nature and Knowledge of Persons," Pacific Philosophy Forum , Vol. 6 (1968), pp. 47-57. 88. Rorty, Amelie Oksenberg, "The Transformations of Persons," Philosophy, Vol. 48 (1973), pp. 261-275. 89. Sanford, David H., "Locke, Leibniz and Wiggins on Being in the Same Place at the Same Time," Philosophical Review, Vol. 79 (1970), pp. 75-82. 90. Shoemaker, Sydney, "On Knowing Who One Is," Common Factor , No. 4, 1966. "Persons and their Pasts," American Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 7 (1970), pp. 269-285. Self-Knowledge and Self-Identity , Ithaca, New York, 1963. "Wiggins on Identity," Philosophical Review, Vol. 79 (1970), pp. 529-544. ' ' ~ 91. Smart, Brian J. , "How to Reidentify the Ship of Theseus." Analysis , Vol. 32 (1972), pp. 145-148. "Personal Identity in an Organized Parcel," Philosophical Studies , Vol. 24 (1973), pp. 420-423. 92. Stevenson, Leslie F,, "Relative Identity and Leibniz's Law," Philo - so phical Q ua rterly , Vol. 22 (1972), pp. 155-158. 93. Trover, John, Review of H. D. Lewis, The Elusive Mind , Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 69 (1972), pp. 168-173. 94. Vaught, Carl G., "The Identity of Indiscernibles and the Concept of Substance," The Southern Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 6 (1968), pp, 152-158. ~ 95. Vision, Gerald, "Essentialism and the Sense of Proper Names," American Philosophical Quarterly , Vol. 7 (1970), pp. 321-330. 96. von Leyden, W. , "What is a Nominal Essence the Essence of?" in Yolton, J. W. , ed., John Locke: Problems and Perspectives , A C ollection of New Essays , Cambridge, 1969, pp. 224-233. 97. Wallace, Kyle, "Shoemaker and Personal Identity," The Personal ist , Vol. 54 (1973) , pp. 71-74. 98. Wiggins, David, Identity and Spatio-Temporal Continuity , Oxford, 1967. "On Being in the Same Place at the Same Time," Philosophical Review , Vol. 77 (1968), pp. 90-95. 99. Williams, Bernard, "Bodily Continuity and Personal Identity, A Reply," Anal ysis , Vol, 21 (1960), pp. 43-48. "Personal Identity and Individuation," Proceedings of the Aristotelian Soc iety , Vol. 57 (1956-1957), p. 229ff.' "The Self and the Future," Phil osophical Review, Vol. 79 (197C)i pp. 161-180. 265 100. Wilson, N. L., "Space, Time and Individuals," Journa l of Philosophy, Vol . 52 (1955), pp. 589-598. ' 101. Woods, M. J. , "Identity and Individuation," in R. J. Butler, ed.. Analytical Philosophy , 2nd Series, Oxford, 1965, pp. 120-130. 102. Woolhouse, R. S., "Geach, Locke and Nominal Essences," Philosophical Studies , Vol. 20 (1969), pp. 77-80. "Locke, Geach and Individual Essences," Philosophical Studies , Vol. 24 (1973), pp. 204-206. 103. Woolhouse, R. S. and Hall, Roland, "Forty Years of Work on John Locke," Philosophical Quarterly (1970), pp. 258-268 and 394-396. "More Addenda to the Locke Bibliography," The Locke Newsletter , Vol. 1 (1970), pp. 5-11. 104. Zemach, E. M. , "Personal Identity Without Criteria," Australasian Journal of Philosophy , Vol. 47 (1969), pp. 344-353.