The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Saturday, April 4, 2020

H. P. Grice and J. O. Urmson: conversation as rational co-operation

Only they would never use such pretentious phrasing!

Grice might -- since he does use 'rational co-operation' in his 'Retrospective epilogue.'

However, on point is key as we review the similiarties between H. P. Grice's approach and one like Urmson's (say, in "Parenthetical verbs,"), or Nowell-Smith's (in, say, "Ethics,") or P. F. Strawson's (and his 'pragmatic rule' in "Introduction to Logical Theory") or J. L. Austin's (in "Other Minds," on 'That's a finch' implying that the utterer KNOWS it's a finch), or C. K. Grant's, -- just to restrict the comparisons to the Play Group.

That point is Grice's explicit, if later, use of expressions from the 'rationality' realm (he was a linguistic botanist). An expectation of conversation is 'reasonable,' or 'rational.'

Other Oxford 'ordinary-language' philosophers may not press the point like Grice does!

No comments:

Post a Comment