The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label "The Secret of their Eyes". Show all posts
Showing posts with label "The Secret of their Eyes". Show all posts

Saturday, April 3, 2010

Implicatures in Na'vi

--- by JLS
------ for the GC

---- I AM ASHAMED TO ADMIT I HAVEN'T YET seen Avatar ('why?' -- meaning, why are you ashamed, rather than why haven't I seen it -- detecting some mock apologetic tone which is usually of the hateful type) but found this in today's World Wide Words thing ed. by M. Quinion:

"NUME NA'VI If you have long envied students of Klingon, you can
now startle them with your knowledge of Na'vi, the language of the
big blue aliens in Avatar: http://www.learnnavi.org/."

And I have NOT checked that either, but hey.

I wonder:

--- vocabulary of Na'vi: does it range over ALL types of predicabilia as in English, or is it narrower than English in scope? Or broader? Who was the linguistic adviser in film? (I recall a French film called "Fire!" had Anthony Burgess as advisor and was based on the idea of prehistoric man's language.

--- syntax, semantics, I don't care much, but...

--- pragmatics, yes. Are there implicatures in Na'vi? Of what type? Do they follow the co-operative principle (As Kramer said, "South Park" on earth features the tricky expression, 'on earth', as ambiguous -- seeing that South Park is an anime. In the case of Na'vi, it's not even there. I assume they DO follow the cooperative principle and even the four conversational categories: to wit: qualitas, quantitas, relatio and modus. Why, they possibly had a Stagirite among them.

If you can provide your favourite Na'vi implicature do. Recall that in Na'vi, the implicatures are in English. I.e. what follows the 'implicature' sign, +>, is NOT an utterance, but a proposition in 'so-mis-called' Mentalese (in the Na'vi thing). So, I wonder if 'some', in Na'vi, has the implicature, 'not all'. Etc.

--- When Argentine J. Campanella received the Oscar for best-foreign film this last edition of the Oscars, he remarked, with an accent, "I'm glad "Avatar" wasn't nominated for best foreign-language film, for I wouldn't be in this podium elsewise".