The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Monday, February 8, 2010

An Anti-Gricean duet: No offence meant; None taken

Yet another:

You are the daughter of a bitch
-- says the tomcat to Lassie.

She looks disappointed.

"No offence meant", you know.

"None taken", she _THEN_ says. Because she needed the reassurement that none was meant to take it".

Grice writes:

"The kind of moral, or more or less moral, distaste for things is one which I feel that, as someone brought up in the enlightened 'pinko' (at least on the surface) atmosphere of Oxford, as it used to be [remember I lose interest in
anything post-1967. JLS] I understand very well. We are in reaction against our Victorian forebears [who made beautiful bronze busts, though. JLS]; we are independent and we are tolerant of the independence of others, unless they go too far. We don't like discipline [but why did fellows a la "Another Country" ended
up in dictatorship Russia?] (Conception of Value, p. 58).

"And we go by Freedom and Resentment".

--- Strawson's point:

"If no offence was meant how can one be taken?"

The repartee, "None taken" is super-superfluous on the face of the co-conversationalist having just said that none was meant.

No comments:

Post a Comment