The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Tuesday, March 31, 2020

H. P. Grice on the buletic-doxastic distinction

Image may contain: possible text that says 'H. P. Grice: the primacy of the buletic over the doxastic'

Grice on Frege

Image may contain: text

Gilbert Ryle attends one of Grice's Play Group's meetings!

Image may contain: 1 person, possible text that says 'H. P. Grice cites from Gilbert Ryle's "The Concept of Mind Mind.'

H. P. Grice agreed with Tarski about 'snow is white' being true if and only if snow is white -- but not with Davidson about 'snow is white' being true if and only if grass is green

Image may contain: 1 person, text

H. P. Grice and R. M. Hare discuss the neustic-phrastic distinction: "Post the letter; therefore, post the letter or burn it!"

Image may contain: possible text that says 'R. M. Hare on H. P. Grice on the implicatum of the buletic "if"'

H. P. Grice: "Paton's essay opened new paths for me!"

Image may contain: 1 person, closeup, possible text that says 'H. B. Paton's "Categorical Imperative" in Griceian key'

H. P. Grice reads Paton's "Categorical Imperative" and understands it -- even if does not "agree with one word in it!"

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice on alcohol-free, sugar-free, and implicature-free

Image may contain: text

Grice thought that Kant's use of 'autonomy' was more serious than his use of 'freedom'

Image may contain: possible text that says 'Kant's Autonomy Part of what it means to have reason and will is to be autonomous-seli governing. When we use people, we violate this autonomy and no longer treat them as people, but as objects or things. Cf. H. P. Grice's meta-ethics'

Grice distinguishes between 'hypothetical' and 'conditional;' Austin doesn't!

Image may contain: possible text that says 'H. P. Grice on "if": suppositional VS. conditional'

H. P. Grice and The Oxford Conversazione Society

G

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice on G. E. Moore and the Cambridge Apostles

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice: "I wish that I had been Napoleon"



No photo description available.

Urmson's Apples and Grice's Cabbages

No photo description available.

"My neighbour's three-year old child understand Russell's Theory of Types": the implicature

It's a piece of cake?

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice on "Never contradict," Jacky Fisher on "Never explain"

Image may contain: 1 person, standing and text

H. P. Grice and J. O. Urmson on Grecian versus Griceian




Image may contain: text

"Perhaps he shouldn't have translated it!" -- H. P. Grice

Grice liked his tutees to read Grecian!

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice on Simplicius: "He has beautiful handwriting -- if it is indeed his!"

No photo description available.

H. P. Grice was amused by the fact that J. L. Austin borrowed 'operative' from Scots law -- "but never returned it!"

Image may contain: text

H. P. Grice and J. O. Urmson on the implicatures of supererogation



Image may contain: possible text that says 'Saints and Heroes O. Urmson Philosophers have too often ignored supererogatory actions. The ideal moral code should distinguish between basic rules and the "higher flights of morality" exemplified by saintliness and heroism.'

H. P. Grice on J. O. Urmson on the emotive theory of ethics

No photo description available.

H. P. Grice and R. M. Hare -- The Conversational Implicature Connection!


Image may contain: text

"Perhaps Strawson should have titled his essay in descriptive metaphysics 'Individuum'" -- H. P. Grice

H. P. Grice on C. L. Stevenson on the expression-communication distinction

commūnĭcātĭo , ōnis, f. communico (several times in Cic., elsewh. rare),
I.a making commonimpartingcommunicating.
I. In gen.: “largitio et communicatio civitatis,” Cic. Balb. 13, 31: “quaedam societas et communicatio utilitatum,” id. Fin. 5, 23, 65: “consilii,” id. Fam. 5, 19, 2: “sermonis,” id. Att. 1, 17, 6: criminis cum pluribus, Tiro ap. Gell. 7, 3, 14: “nominum,” i. e. the like appellation of several objectsPlin. 24, 14, 80, § 129: “juris,” Dig. 23, 2, 1: “damni,” ib. 27, 3, 1, § 14.—
II. In rhet., a figure of speech, = ἀνακοίνωσιςin accordance with which one turns to his hearersandas it wereallows them to take part in the inquiryCic. de Or. 3, 53, 204Quint. 9, 1, 309, 2, 20 and 23.

Note Cicero's connection of it with "anakoinosis." The idea of the 'common' is crucial

"Anakoinosis" is a figure of speech discussed by Cicero, where the utterer displays a figure 'in accordance with which the utterer turns to his addressee, and, as it were, allows his utterer to take part in whatever it is that the utterer is engaged.
Grice finds Stevenson's appeal to 'communication' circular, or not helpful, in "Meaning."