The Grice Club

Welcome

The Grice Club

The club for all those whose members have no (other) club.

Is Grice the greatest philosopher that ever lived?

Search This Blog

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Webster's Ghost As Exorcised by Grice

The document read,

D or d

--

Webster, who had a thing for dictionaries, read that, clumsily as

Dord

-- since it featured in a physics manual defining or daffining 'density' he entried it in his dicttionary:

dord: density

--- This is referred to as Webster's ghost, which is properly exorcised by Grice, of course:

1. If meaning is, as Grice says,
a matter of "intentions",
is a "ghost word" or item like 'dord'
really a "word"
(see his "Utterer's meaning, sentence meaning
and word meaning", in WoW). Is it an
utterance-part. Yes, for Webster. Although
he only 'mentioned' it, never _used_ it.

2. Can a "ghost word" or item cease to be so?
Yes. I.e. if
English people start _using_ (as they should --
"We love Webster -- he's from Connecticut alright",
that sort of thing) "dord" to mean "density"
there will be a procedure in the repertoire
of a group for which 'dord'
does mean "density". As when Grice told Schiffer
that in Oxford, 'we should get together and have
lunch sometime' _means_ 'later'.

3. Ross Eckler wrote on this in 1996.

Etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment